Center for Story and Spirit
  • Home
  • About
    • Michael's Story
    • Clients + Testimonials
    • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Offerings
    • For Organizations
    • For Individuals
    • Breathwork & Meditation on Insight Timer
    • Inner Dance
    • Gifts For You
  • Articles & Resources
    • Articles & Musings
    • Ethical Storytelling
  • Contact

Articles + Musings

The 'Innovation' Trap: Unintended Consequences of Solving the Wrong Problem

7/9/2018

6 Comments

 
Picture
The problems of poverty, disease, and environmental decay cannot be solved merely by the use of more and more scientific technology. Technological fixes usually turn out to be a jumble of procedures that have unpredictable consequences and are often in conflict with natural forces. Indeed, technological magic is not much better than primitive magic in dealing with the fundamental issues of human existence, and in addition, it is much more destructive.
–Rene Dubos, 1967


At a recent conference billed as an exploration of the intersection of Social Impact and Exponential Technologies, a prominent tech luminary spoke on the increasing incidence of depression and how technology will be essential to dealing with it.

She walked us through data showing that depression is projected to increase several-fold in the next decade. Other data laid out the developed world’s current capacity to treat depression. There was a clear and growing gap. We simply will not have the resources to handle the epidemic.

We must, the speaker said, find a way to increase our capacity to serve those grappling with depression. It’s not possible to train enough therapists in time to offer support. Fortunately, exponential technology, specifically adaptive intelligence, can help.

Currently, those working with depression have limited options for getting support. Almost all of them involve having to find and vet a therapist, go to therapy consistently, and/or get a prescription medication. With adaptive intelligence, help could be as close as an app on your phone.

The speaker walked us through a use case. Someone feels unmotivated, disconnected, and depressed. They log on to a secure (much emphasis was placed on ‘secure’) app and are greeted by an adaptive Artificial Intelligence that approximates warmth and curiosity. With a few questions customized to inspire reflection and sharing, the AI triages users.

Some people may only need a bit of space for reflection. For them, the AI provides the necessary level of support.

Others may require more intensive support. The AI detects this and links them to a trained therapist for a consultation.

This technology driven solution solves for the problem of capacity. Exponential technology saves the day.

I listened to the talk with a growing sense of dread and frustration in my gut.
Much as I may have my doubts about AI, the solution the speaker proposed didn’t raise my hackles. It was the fact that it grew out of, I believe, the wrong question and therefore solved the wrong problem.

Working from solid data sets, the speaker had developed a question: how do we expand the capacity of the mental health sector to confront the increase in depression?

The AI solution could work. And it has the advantage of being scalable.

But if we zoom out a bit, we can see that the solution could have unintended consequences.

By expanding society’s capacity to ‘deal with’ depression, the proposed AI would support the social structures, behaviors, and beliefs that often lead to depression in the first place. Furthermore, by driving people towards greater engagement with technology, it potentially deepens social isolation and the disintegration of interpersonal community.


In other words, it solves the symptom of a deeper problem and, in the process, potentially exacerbates the root problem.

I found myself curious about what would happen if the question the speaker had asked had been more along the lines of ‘what is causing this dramatic rise in depression and how can technology contribute to a deep, lasting solution?’

One of the major causes of depression in developed countries is social isolation and lack of vibrant community. As we become more technologically advanced, we depend less on our community for survival. In many countries, it’s possible to move through an entire week without meaningful social interaction. That lack of interaction leads to feelings of purposelessness, disconnection, and depression. It has gotten so severe that the UK recently appointed a Minister of Loneliness to address the challenges posted by mounting isolation.

What if, instead of using technology as a stop-gap measure, it were used to bring people together in community for meaningful interaction? In other words, what if we put people, instead of technology, at the center of the solution?

‘Innovation’ has become something of a buzzword over the last decade. As has ‘disruption.’ Here’s a question:

If Rene Dubos, writing in the mid-20th Century, identified the same issue and wrote essentially what I just wrote (albeit much more eloquently) over 50 years ago, how innovative or disruptive are these new technological solutions?

If we look at them in relative isolation, they represent technological innovation. AI is new. AI is disruptive in the short-term.

But if we widen our lens to, again, zoom out, what do we see?

I believe we see a civilization that has long turned to technology and scientific ‘miracles’ to solve human problems to the detriment of the broader community and even the planet. There’s nothing truly innovative about this. It’s a new iteration of an old pattern.

I’m not a luddite. Technology is cool and useful.

I am, however, suggesting that true innovation and disruption would put human beings, with all of their complexity and hard-wired need for connection, support, and community, at the center of technological development. True innovation would employ technology as a tool to bring us into greater alignment with ‘natural forces’–with the earth, our own intuition, with each other–instead of simply solving surface level manifestations of deeper challenges.

Imagine what that disruption would look like.

​
6 Comments
Dwain Perry
7/10/2018 02:32:26 pm

Imagine, indeed. I'm thinking a John Lennon type of imagine.

Reply
Michael Kass
7/10/2018 03:00:40 pm

Indeed. Me, too! And it starts at the micro level before we can all sing together (not to torture the metaphor too much).

Reply
Avary Kent link
7/11/2018 09:05:42 pm

This is the heart of how risky it is to focus on bandaids and symptoms. When I studied Dr. Deming's work in grad school the process of the 5 whys and getting to root cause analysis struck me as one of the most important skills we could be applying to society. Why is depression a growing concern? Why do people feel increasingly isolated? Why can we go through a week without any real meaningful human interaction?

While I'm excited by some of the potential of this kind of AI to get those to admit their symptoms who might otherwise be unable to do with a therapist (one of the examples that was shared was with Veterans with PTSD) - the scaleable solution seems to be connecting people to small groups for interaction, support, and connection. Hence why we've seen AA, Weightwatchers, Masterminds, and many other iterations of intimate groups of people coming together to make positive change in their lives - these solutions can scale - and I for one am really excited about the training and capacity building opportunities to help more people host these kinds of conversations.

Reply
Michael Kass
7/12/2018 08:44:56 am

Couldn't agree more (which is not really a huge surprise :))! It's almost like we have to retrain ourselves to be human with each other after 2+ centuries of looking to technology outside of ourselves for 'solutions.'

Reply
The Dice Pattern Trap link
10/3/2022 10:18:08 am

I Read this post. Here is advice that about Dice pattern. You can know more service the following website.
The Dice Pattern Trap The True Story Of A Pissed Off Problem Gambler. Fifteen Pages Of Nonsense. The Dice Pattern Trap is the most controversial book of our time. FREE DOWNLOAD!
Please visit here- https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCE6tzvhhfhhrCCCqgOaRvdw

Reply
fix my speaker link
1/6/2023 03:20:28 am

Did you drop your phone in the pool? toilet? Leaving water inside your speaker can harm your speaker and all your phone hardware.
Don’t worry, we have the solution for you to repair your speaker and iphone!

Sound to get water out of phone for a speaker fix

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Write something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview.

    Archives

    September 2020
    June 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    November 2019
    August 2019
    May 2019
    March 2019
    January 2019
    October 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018

    Categories

    All
    Breathwork
    Healing
    Leadership
    Mindful Communication
    Nonprofit
    Organizational Culture
    Public Speaking
    Social Impact
    Spirit
    Story
    Story Maps
    Storytelling
    Technology

    RSS Feed

  • Home
  • About
    • Michael's Story
    • Clients + Testimonials
    • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Offerings
    • For Organizations
    • For Individuals
    • Breathwork & Meditation on Insight Timer
    • Inner Dance
    • Gifts For You
  • Articles & Resources
    • Articles & Musings
    • Ethical Storytelling
  • Contact